Even Judges Get it Wrong? - September 2020



As a plaintiff, you may have heard the lawyers use the expression – “the assessment of damages is not an accurate science” and this is amply borne out in the Court of Appeal decision of McKeown -v- Crosby, given in August 2020.


In March 2017 Mc Keown was making a right turn when Crosby who was trying to overtake crashed into her. In December 2019, at a very short hearing, the high court awarded €70,000 for her pain and suffering and another €6,000 for her expenses.


On appeal by the defendant the judges cited previous judgements stating that damages should be proportional to social conditions and the general level of incomes and on that basis reduced the award for pain and suffering to €35,000.


If we are to follow the court of appeal, then personal injury awards during Covid will be coming down.


If you are a plaintiff, self-insured or are in the unfortunate position of finding yourself uninsured and you need advice please contact us today.

Recent Posts

See All

The Commercial Court Zooms Ahead - February 2021

The Commercial Court is soon to hear a case by “Trialview”, which is the court's version of Zoom. This is the same system that was used by Justice Denis Mc Donald in the recent insurance case involvin

Damages Taking a Beating? - February 2021

In the recent Court of Appeal case, Leidig v. O’Neill [2020] IECA 296, damages for a fractured wrist were significantly reduced. This is yet another example of a decision exerting downward pressure on

McErlean Weir | LAW FIRM

© 2018 by McErlean Weir Law Firm. Proudly created by Sika Media

Fourteen Fitzwilliam Square  |  Dublin 2  |  D02 W298  |  Ireland |  T: +353 1 2551511  |  E: [email protected]